Wednesday, 27 October 2010

Miscellaneous Snowbank Lake Gear Notes

A little late, but I have a few left-over gear, ongoing-use notes that don't yet qualify for full review status...


Kooka Bay air pillow
I ordered a custom sized pillow from Kooka Bay. It's the first time I've used an air pillow - previously I used my clothes bag, but when carrying fewer clothes the bag started to get a little uncomfortable. I sleep on my side, and like a large, comfy pillow, so i hoped that the Kooka Bay would suit me.

I feel a little underwhelmed by it, to be honest. It is light - 63g - slightly les than the Exped pillow (85g), but the nylon material is quite slippery, and I never got entirely comfortable on it. Half inflated, my head lolled around, and even with silicone spots glued underneath it still slid around on the Ether Elite.

One of the other hikers had an Exped pillow, and the surface on that was quite soft in comparison - it has a coating which just feels nicer against the skin. The shape - a crescent - is more suited to side-sleepers also, and the internal supports are vertical rather than horizontal, which I believe would limit that lolling around feeling I got with the Kooka Bay.

I have to say I'm still on the fence about pillows; I'm wondering if they are really worth their weight.

Golite UltraLite 3 Season Quilt - Long
Golite's recent trend of going-slightly-heavier continued when they re-released the Golite Ultra 20 with a little more down and a more water-resistant material on the footbox and shoulder, and called it the Golite UltraLite 3 Season. Mine weighs in at 837g, which isn't bad, but there are much lighter quilts out there.

I've slept in it now about 10 nights, and really enjoyed the freedom of movement a quilt provides. It's plenty warm enough for spring and autumn, but a little too warm for summer (at least in Minnesota).

The waterproof breathable Pertex Shield foot and shoulder material sheds condensation from the tarp inner very well, and inside a bivy it's very cosy. I could prabably get away without the bivy under the DuoMid.

I have the long version, and there was plenty of length for me to pull over my head and snuggle down underneath. In theory it could be used in moderate winter conditions, but I prefer a full sleeping bag to keep out the chills.

POE Ether Elite 6
I found this pad to be comfortable and warm enough without an under pad - although the conditions were not cold enough to need that anyway. I definitely felt less likely to roll off the pad, compared to the NeoAir.

I added some silicon drops to the base of the pad to stop it sliding around in the bivy, but they didn't adhere properly to the pad material. I'll try pasting some on the bivy next time. I managed to improvise a solution tying the UltraLite's webbing around the pad and through the loops on the bivy floor. It worked well enough.

Out of NeoAir habit, I under-inflated the pad, and by morning found I had a numb arm. Next time I'll try a full inflation.

On the whole, I was satisfied, and at 396g for a long it's a good weight - but POE have already discontinued it, and released an improved version with a NeoAir-style reflective insulation.  I look forward to reading more about that when some reviews come in.

Sawyer Water Filter
Once again, where other people's SteriPens failed, the trusty Sawyer continued to filter water at a rapid pace. It is infinitely better than my old MSR pump filter - one of my hiking companions was using the Hyperflow and faced the same efficiency meltdown that I did last year up in the Boundary Waters. But the Sawyer just keeps on flowing. No technology to go wrong. No batteries needed. It just works. 71g of worry-free water, at about 1 liter a minute.

But... I managed to break off the outlet nipple while trying to remove the tubing. Fortunately, duct tape solved the problem, at least for the duration of the trip.

BushBuddy Ultra
It might take a little longer than firing up a gas stove, but the BushBuddy just gives me wood-fuelled joy every time I use it. It's fun to gather fuel from the trail and around camp, and relaxing to feed the flames and watch the pot boil.

Inov-8 Terroc 295
These were great to walk in. I loved the grip, and the protection around the toes and sides kept sharp rocks and sticks away from my feet. The mesh ventilated well, and dried very quickly. I didn't have to make many river crossings, but I did give them a good soaking in a lake just to test how they (and I) coped with wet feet, and how long it took them to dry while walking. Walking was fine when wet, and they were dry in 1-2 hours.

The shoes are deliriously light compared to anything else I own - even sandals - and although I didn't spend a long time wearing them in, I had no discomfort during the hike.

About a week after the trip, a horrible pain flared up in my foot. I don't know what it was because as usual I couldn't be bothered to go to the doctor, but it felt and looked like tendonitis, and lasted about a week. Whether this was a result of the Inov-8s I do not know, but I suspect it might have been the result of not being used to non-supportive shoes and using them on a long distance hike.

But I'm wearing them still and feeling fine, so maybe it was something else.

MLD Burn
The Burn was packed just about to it's limit. I don't know why, but I seemed to be carrying more weight than I should, even after paring the pack list down. But for most of the hike the Burn handled it comfortably and without any trouble.

The mesh pockets do require some care, and there were a couple of occasions when a branch snagged the pack and I was worried that it might have ripped the mesh - but no. It held up well to some pretty hard trail conditions.

The pack is very slim, but there's plenty of room for all the accoutrements of UL hiking, and the roominess of the mesh pockets is great. The front pocket fits a DuoMid with ease.

The top of the front mesh pocket was the only problem - the elastic tensioner at the top of the pocket kept disappearing into the Dyneema sleeve. It definitely needs a couple of plastic toggles to prevent this. A modification is in order!

The hip belt, under a full load, sits just a touch above my hips, but as it's not really supposed to be a load-bearing hip belt, that's not a huge deal. However, after three days, I did find my shoulders were aching, which leads me to believe that the Burn is really best suited to very minimal summer trips.

At 414g, it's super-light, too.

MLD Duomid
The Duomid was almost perfect. With all the talk about Trailstars recently I began to wonder whether I'd picked the right shelter. What I like about the Duomid is that I can leave the doors open if I choose, creating a kind of three-sided lean-to. It's extremely simple to pitch, and easy to tweak into storm-worthy mode.

Nitpicks? The need to clip-up the bottom when zipping or unzipping, maybe, to ease tension off the zipper - that's a bit fiddly. It also takes up a fair amount of space - which makes it a little tricky in forested spaces - and needs a relatively flat spot to pitch it well. To achieve a vertical pitch on a slope you end up with the head end low the the ground and the foot end pretty high. Last, it's a little heavy (614g, guys and stuffsack included). It seems ridiculous to say that, but the SpinnTwinn feels lighter than air at 305g.

My main preference over what I've seen of the Trailstar so far is that I don't have to crawl to get in it, although I'm told that it's entrance is about the same height as the SpinnTwinn.

Haglöfs Trail Pants
I've had these for some years now, and they no longer have the product name  visible anywhere, but they are my go-to hiking trousers for cooler temperatures. They are water-resistant, quick-drying, and very sturdy. They have reinforced, crampon-proof material on the bottom, breath well, and have a flexible material on the knees. They're not really UL (544g), but for clothing that I know I won't need to carry at any point, I don't really care. I have never been in a situation where I found myself saying "Damn, I wish my trousers were a bit lighter."


10 comments:

  1. A great set of kit in my opinion - the DuoMid/Trailstar debate will run and run and I'm a bit bored of it now! I've got both and I'll continue to use both depending on my mood.

    I'm unconvinced by the one inflatable pillow I've tried (the popular yellow Mammut model) - I've not noticed improved sleep using it and my shoes seem to function just as well when deployed with the appropriate moisture/odour barrier.

    The MLD Burn appeals - I've not seen an MLD pack in the flesh but the proportions seem pretty spot on.

    Thanks for the write-up, it's great to see what others are using.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I couldn't be without my Exped pillow. It's the best I've tried. Shoes/stuffsack don't do it for me. If you want to secure your pillow, use a piece of shockcord: http://blogpackinglight.wordpress.com/2010/07/11/gear-stuff-part-2/

    McNett silicone sealant sticks to the POE Ether Elite and stops it sliding.

    Not used my Duomid yet, but looking forward to summer next year when I can.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Phil: The DuoMid and Trailstar are both great. Choosing between them is a bit "six of one, half a dozen of the other". It's pretty impressive that MLD have produced two of the best shelters out there. And while we're on the subject of MLD, the Burn is a great pack for short tips with condensed gear. It forces you to pack tight, but you can get a surprising amount in. I'll do a full review after I've used it a little more.

    Robin: I plan to try an Exped. If that doesn't work I'll go back to a stuffsack full of clothes.

    I tried neat SilNet on the base, but it peeled off overnight.

    I didn't know you had a DuoMid - I look forward to reading about your experiences with it!

    ReplyDelete
  4. The SilNet I used has stuck like a limpit to my POE Ether. Strange!

    Unfortunately my Duomid arrived a bit late in the year.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I am out with the DuoMid this weekend Robin. Get it out there. I have a Trailstar coming Mark as I like the reviews on it. Having options is good and as Phil says use kit depending on your mood and need. Kit wise your list is a good one and experimenting one short trips to gage what will work on a big trip.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I'm agreeing with Martin, Roger. I plan to use the DuoMid as my winter shelter. No excuses!

    I'd love to have both the Trailstar and DuoMid (and... and... and...), but my finances are somewhat limited at the moment. If that changes however...

    Big trips are also temporarily on hold for other reasons, but I'm happy to get out when I can and make the most of it.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Mark -comments to several items.
    I cannot get on with Terrocs 345's and the
    y have caused me foot pain. Don't know whether it is the design or me. I really wanted to like them as like you they have a lot of good attributes.

    Pillow - I have a Primasilk pillow from Intergal Design which I get on fine with and I am a fussy sod regarding pillows.

    Golite quilt - seems sort of heavy to my mind- I was very interested in this, but it is quite heavy compared to my 3 season Alpkit bag.

    Mark Good post - I like this type as it brings to my attention gear I probably would not find out about elsewhere.
    Mark

    ReplyDelete
  8. Mark - the GoLite quilt is not the lightest, but it is a good entry point to quilting, and considerably cheaper than many of the (admittedly better) cottage industry quilts. At some point I'll upgrade, but it's adequate for the moment. I just read Chris Townsend used one on his recent PNT hike.

    I picked up a Exped pillow yesterday - will try it out next week.

    ReplyDelete
  9. DuoMid, TrailStar, and whatever else. In my opinion UL also has much to do with using (and learning to use) the gear you have, and make it work. Lighten the load of your gear closet instead of adding to it, so that you can use what the situation might call for instead of choosing between fifty shelters and thirty sleeping bags.

    Nice piece, Mark. I'd Flattr you if I could ;)

    ReplyDelete
  10. Nice round-up Mark. It's interesting to see certain items becoming go-to pieces for many of us, reinforcing the theory that good design wins through. The Trailstar v DuoMid debate is the new Laser Comp v Akto debate. Ron is the real winner here ;-)

    The BBU is truly a work of genius. Efficient, well-made, aesthetically pleasing, simple. It also possesses that unquantifiable quality of enhancing the camp/cooking experience, tapping in to some kind of primeval need for hunter/gathering and the security provided by man's harnessing of fire.

    I agree that GoLite, despite the recent increase in product weights, is still a relevant manufacturer of 'UL' equipment. They provide 'entry point' UL equipment for the masses. Good pricing and availability will lure many people towards 'enlightenment'. Some will progress to more specialised 'cottage manufacturer' gear and lower weights but the combination of a GoLite Jam, appropriately sized Shangri-La shelter and Ultralite 3-season quilt is still, in my opinion, a fantastic place for people to start out.

    ReplyDelete